Wednesday, August 15, 2018

Risks of Cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrencies and blockchains are now all the rage. In 1999, if your startup ended in "dot com", people threw money at you; today, if your startup has something to do with blockchain or cryptocurrency, likewise.
I am naturally a skeptic having seen a handful of boom-and-bust cycles in technology. It's not that I'm skeptical about enthusiasm for a new technology per se. I am as much an early adopter and techno-apologist as anyone.  Indeed, in 2007, along with the RAD Lab at Berkeley where I was a researcher at the time, we cheered loudly for Amazon's new "public utility" style cloud computing (EC2, or Elastic Compute Cloud), against skeptics who thought it was hype/nothing fundamentally new. Ten years later, Amazon owns >30% of the infrastructure services market on the strength of its utility-computing offerings, and Netflix, one of the largest app installations on the planet, relies entirely on EC2 for its computing. This is largely in keeping with what we predicted would happen.
But sometimes, there are elements of techno-optimism about a new techno-fad that seem to wilfully ignore economic reality, technical reality, social reality, or a combination of the three. For example. in the late 90s, peer-to-peer filesharing was going to make centralized servers obsolete. The reasons given were many: P2P didn't rely on a single centralized point of coordination or failure (if properly designed and implemented); "spare" cycles and storage around the network could be harnessed to store and process data, rather than paying for centralized capacity to do so; Big Evil Governments would be unable to take down P2P networks acting in ways they didn't like; and so on.
In fact, my advisor at the time, Eric Brewer (now VP Infrastructure at Google), argued persuasively that from a technical and economic perspective, centralization made more sense than distribution. A centralized cluster that's well-run requires fewer human resources per server, can be made more secure and more reliable because all the eggs are in one basket to which dedicated attention can be given, and so on. He was right: Amazon EC2 is the manifestation of exactly that. It is true that there are still good reasons to use P2P, in particular when evasion of censorship or takedown is needed because the site is trafficking in illegal goods. Yes, there is a free-speech argument to be made, but overwhelmingly, the uses of P2P have been to facilitate transactions or discourse that society has already agreed should be illegal.
Similarly, the 2005 "One Laptop Per Child" $100 laptop was supposed to be the technical innovation that would get laptops and the Internet into the hands of children in developing countries, but it failed miserably in doing that. While the prototype did feature some technical innovations, the nonprofit's founders and spiritual leaders had little experience in either large-scale hardware procurement or the politics of development projects in foreign countries. The OLPC, with its one-off technology and quirky bespoke OS, was rapidly eclipsed by $200-400 Intel-based subnotebooks running Windows, and the resulting momentum arguably created that new product category; today Chromebooks can be had for under $100 from various vendors.
In the spirit of tempering techno-optimism with doses of socio-political-economic reality, I had a great time reading Nick Weaver's devastating critique of cryptocurrencies in last month's Communications of the ACM (Inside Risks: Risks of Cryptocurrency, CACM 61(6), June 2018). Nick was a grad student in systems at Berkeley at about the same time I was, and is now a security researcher at Berkeley's International Computer Science Institute. In his essay, he argues persuasively that cryptocurrencies are neither fit for purpose as a stable store of value, nor are they invulnerable to mutation as proponents claim, nor is their control sufficiently distributed in practice to avoid having to trust a small cabal of entities that effectively control most of the wealth, in addition to which the presence of bugs in the code can lead to situations that are catastrophic not only for individual coin holders but for entire societies.
The prose is not polemical or hyperbolic, but it is implacable, relentless, and dryly sardonic in the style of something like Why Pascal Is Not My Favorite Programming Language, and it musters its evidence well. Suffice to say it affirmed my original decision (on which I've never wavered) to stay the hell away from cryptocurrencies.
To be fair, P2P and OLPC had important follow-on effects, and their development resulted in important ideas that play key roles as part of today's ecosystem (which, coincidentally, is focused on centralized servers serving commodity-built clients). It's just that the ideas haven't been deployed in the way envisioned by their creators, because the socio-technical arguments underlying their positions were uncertain to begin with and readily crumbled.
Go read Nick's article. If you like it, feel free to tip him in Bitcoin.

9 comments:

  1. Nice blog posting information
    Sanjary Kids is one of the best play school and preschool in Hyderabad,India. Give your child the best preschool experience by choosing the best playschool of Hyderabad in Abids. we provide programs like Play group,Nursery,Junior KG,Senior KG,and provides Teacher Training Program.
    pre and primary teacher training course in hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great blog information of the author provided

    Sanjary Academy is the best Piping Design institute in Hyderabad, Telangana. It is the best Piping design Course in India and we have offer professional Engineering Courses like Piping design Course, QA/QC Course, document controller course, Pressure Vessel Design Course, Welding Inspector Course, Quality Management Course and Safety Officer Course.
    Piping Design Course
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad ­
    Piping Design Course in India­

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Excellent topic explanation of the blog

    Pressure Vessel Design Course is one of the courses offered by Sanjary Academy in Hyderabad. We have offer professional Engineering Course like Piping Design Course,QA/QC Course,document Controller course,pressure Vessel Design Course,Welding Inspector Course, Quality Management Course, #Safety officer course.
    Welding Inspector Course
    Safety officer course
    Quality Management Course
    Quality Management Course in India

    ReplyDelete
  6. Excellent information for this blog
    "Sanjary Academy provides excellent training for Piping design course. Best Piping Design Training Institute in Hyderabad,
    Telangana. We have offer professional Engineering Course like Piping Design Course,QA / QC Course,document Controller
    course,pressure Vessel Design Course, Welding Inspector Course, Quality Management Course, #Safety officer course."
    Piping Design Course in India­
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    Piping Design Course in Hyderabad
    QA / QC Course
    QA / QC Course in india
    QA / QC Course in Hyderabad
    Document Controller course
    Pressure Vessel Design Course
    Welding Inspector Course
    Quality Management Course
    Quality Management Course in india
    Safety officer course

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice Information
    Yaaron Studios is one of the rapidly growing editing studios in Hyderabad. We are the best Video Editing services in Hyderabad. We provides best graphic works like logo reveals, corporate presentation Etc. And also we gives the best Outdoor/Indoor shoots and Ad Making services.
    video editors studio in hyderabad
    short film editors in hyderabad
    corporate video editing studio in hyderabad
    ad making company in hyderabad

    ReplyDelete